All Modern is an online retailer offering a wide selection of trend-focused modern furniture at accessible prices, while West Elm is a well-known brand specializing in mid-century modern designs with a strong emphasis on sustainability, quality craftsmanship, and ethical sourcing. Key differences lie in All Modern's broad, budget-friendly inventory from various manufacturers versus West Elm's curated, in-house collections sold at a higher, mid-range price point.
Let's compare everything you need to know to decide which of these popular retailers is the right fit for your home and style.
All Modern: The Affordable Modern Retailer
All Modern is a member of the Wayfair family of brands, operating as a one-stop shop for contemporary and modern furniture. It caters to young professionals and first-time homeowners who want a sleek, minimalist aesthetic without a significant investment. The platform is known for its extensive, constantly updated catalog that reflects the latest interior design trends at competitive prices.
- Product mix: A vast selection of furniture for every room, including sofas, beds, dining tables, decor accents, and outdoor pieces. They aggregate offerings from countless manufacturers, providing extensive choice.
- Style/vibe: Clean-lined contemporary, minimalist, and Scandinavian-inspired designs. The aesthetic is heavily trend-driven and focused on creating uncluttered, modern spaces.
- Price point: Generally budget-friendly to mid-range. Sofas often start around $300–$500, dining tables from $200–$600, and bed frames in the $300–$700 range. Frequent sales make pricing even more competitive.
- Quality: Quality is variable as products are sourced from many different suppliers. Pieces often use engineered woods, MDF, and budget-friendly fabrics, making them suitable for the price but potentially less durable for long-term, heavy use.
- Shopping Experience: Entirely online, featuring a user-friendly website with detailed product specs and thousands of customer reviews to guide purchasing decisions. It's built for convenience and quick turnaround.
- Delivery & Assembly: Free shipping is available for many items. Most furniture requires self-assembly, though some larger items have options for professional assembly at an additional cost.
- Return policy: Most items can be returned within 30 days for a refund or store credit, but return shipping fees are typically deducted.
All Modern is the ideal choice for shoppers needing stylish, modern furniture quickly and on a budget, making it perfect for apartments, starter homes, and spaces that evolve with the trends.
Shop All Modern: allmodern.com
West Elm: The Sustainable, Stylish Choice
Part of the Williams-Sonoma portfolio, West Elm has built its brand around original, modern design with a deep commitment to sustainability and fair-trade practices. It appeals to a style-conscious consumer who values eco-friendly materials and artisanal details and is willing to invest in pieces that blend timeless appeal with contemporary trends. They are also known for helping customers design their space and create a complete furnishing solution.
- Product mix: A comprehensive offering of home furnishings, including living room and bedroom furniture, dining sets, lighting, rugs, and decor. They are also known for textiles and exclusive artist collaborations.
- Style/vibe: Primarily mid-century modern, blended with bohemian, rustic, and artisanal influences. Expect warm wood tones, textured fabrics, and unique handcrafted details.
- Price point: Mid-range to upper-mid-range. Sofas typically run from $1,000–$3,500, dining tables from $800–$2,000, and beds around $1,000–$2,500.
- Quality: Emphasis on high-quality, sustainable materials like FSC-certified solid wood, organic cotton, and linen. Frames for upholstered goods are generally kiln-dried for durability, offering better longevity.
- Customization: Many sofas, sectionals, and chairs offer a wide range of custom fabrics and leg finishes, allowing you to tailor pieces to your decor.
- Shopping Experience: An omnichannel retailer with a sophisticated website and physical showrooms, where customers can see products in person and meet with design experts for free consultations.
- Delivery & Assembly: White-glove delivery service is available, which includes delivery to the room of your choice, full assembly, and packaging removal. Lead times for custom orders can be several weeks.
West Elm is for shoppers seeking durable, thoughtfully designed furniture with a strong environmental and ethical story behind it.
Shop West Elm: westelm.com
All Modern vs. West Elm Comparison
Price Comparison
There's a significant price difference between the two retailers. All Modern is decidedly more budget-friendly across almost every category. A modern 3-seater sofa on All Modern might cost $600, while a comparable style at West Elm would likely start around $1,400. This pattern holds true for beds, dining tables, rugs, and lighting.
All Modern offers great value if your priority is achieving a specific modern look for less. West Elm’s higher prices are justified by better materials, superior construction, sustainability certifications, and original design work. If longevity is prioritized, West Elm often provides better long-term value, as its pieces are built to last.
Quality & Materials
Quality and materials are a primary point of differentiation. West Elm makes sourcing a core part of its brand identity, using FSC-certified woods, handcrafted elements, and organic textiles. Their furniture often features solid wood construction and durable, kiln-dried frames, leading to greater stability and a longer lifespan. They also provide warranties on certain pieces which highlight their confidence in their products.
Because All Modern is a marketplace sourced from many different suppliers, quality can be inconsistent. You'll find a heavy reliance on engineered wood, veneers, and polyester-blend fabrics. While suitable for their price point, these materials are less resilient to daily wear and tear compared to the high-quality materials found at West Elm. Customer reviews on All Modern can provide insights on durability, so it's advisable to research specific products before purchasing, especially for high-touch items like living room sofas or cribs.
Style & Aesthetic
Both brands champion modern design, but their approaches are distinct. All Modern delivers clean lines, sharp angles, and neutral palettes, echoing minimalist or Scandinavian looks. Their catalog is always changing to meet new furniture trends, offering current styles at lower prices.
West Elm heavily favors a mid-century modern aesthetic, one of the most in-demand styles for a more upscale living. Expect tapered wooden legs, organic curves, and rich wood tones. Their designers skillfully incorporate bohemian and artisanal touches, such as hand-woven textures on pillows or marbled patterns on decor - creating spaces that feel both polished and collected over time.
Shopping Experience
All Modern offers a streamlined, efficient online-only shopping journey. Its website uses filters and search tools effectively to help navigate its massive inventory. Customer reviews play a major role in informing purchase decisions due to the lack of physical showrooms for its wide array of listed merchants.
West Elm caters to customers who prefer both online and in-person shopping. Its physical showrooms allow customers to touch upholstery, test sofa firmness, and assess the scale of furniture pieces. West Elm also offers services such as free in-store or virtual design consultations to provide professional-level guidance.
Sustainability & Ethics
West Elm takes a significant lead in sustainability and ethics. It is recognized for its commitment to using fair-trade certified factories, organic materials, and transparent impact reporting. This visibility builds trust and aligns with eco-conscious values.
All Modern does not emphasize sustainability to the same extent. While it may partner with eco-friendly suppliers, this is not a core focus, and consumers may need to investigate further to make environmentally informed choices. For those prioritizing sustainability, West Elm remains the preferred choice.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice depends on your personal priorities: budget, style preference, and how you value sustainability and long-term durability.
Choose All Modern if:
- You're on a tight budget and want the modern look for less.
- You are furnishing a starter home, apartment, or secondary space like an office or children's room.
- You like updating your furniture frequently to keep up with trends.
- You are confident about your own furnishing taste and don't need special assistance.
Choose West Elm if:
- You prioritize sustainability and want to support brands with ethical practices.
- You are investing in a durable piece that will last a decade.
- You love a warm mid-century modern aesthetic with artisanal, crafted, or bohemian styling details.
- You value the support of a large retailer for repairs and customer service for longer-lasting furniture management. West Elm offers readily available repair options, which might be limited with other vendors.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is All Modern or West Elm cheaper?
All Modern is significantly cheaper than West Elm. Its online business model reduces overhead costs, passing on savings to customers. This advantage is detailed throughout this article regarding what each brand offers.
Which has better quality, All Modern or West Elm?
West Elm excels in quality and durability. With kiln-dried woods and eco-friendly, customer-first design processes, they offer a high level of product transparency. All Modern's quality varies due to its marketplace nature, relying on customer reviews for insights. West Elm's commitment to consistent quality makes it an enduring choice for discerning shoppers.
Can you return furniture to both stores?
Yes, both stores allow returns but under different policies. All Modern accepts returns within 30 days, with the cost of return shipping deducted. The process is straightforward and online. West Elm also offers a 30-day return window, but the return of custom-made upholstery is final sale. Non-furniture items can be returned to a store, while larger pieces require delivery services for returns.
Do All Modern and West Elm have showrooms?
Only West Elm has physical showrooms. All Modern is online only, making customer reviews and images critical for gaining insights before purchase.
Which brand ships furniture faster?
All Modern typically ships faster. Items often ship within a few days, smaller goods can arrive quickly with standard options. West Elm's made-to-order items take longer, sometimes several weeks, emphasizing the bespoke nature of their offerings.
Is assembly required for West Elm furniture deliveries?
Some West Elm furniture may require assembly, but many orders offer white-glove service. This includes in-home delivery and setup, removing packaging and providing peace of mind, which distinguishes West Elm as a leader in customer satisfaction during the delivery process.
Which brand is recommended for a child's nursery?
West Elm offers a line of kids' furnishings with a focus on safety and non-toxic finishes, making it a preferred choice for children's rooms. While All Modern provides affordable options for short-term use, such as rocking chairs or cribs, the emphasis on safety and manufacturing materials makes West Elm a more secure choice.
Do these brands offer wedding registries?
Both brands have wedding registry options, but for broader options and different budget levels, All Modern is a part of a larger marketplace which might be more suitable for diverse gift preferences compared to West Elm's program.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
