The All-Clad NS1 and HA1 grill pans are both premium indoor grilling options, but they differ primarily in their cooking surface and intended use. The NS1 features a rugged, all-metal stainless steel construction designed for high-heat searing and professional-style results, while the HA1 comes with a PFOA-free non-stick coating that prioritizes easy food release and effortless cleanup. This core difference makes the NS1 a workhorse for durability and intense heat, while the HA1 is built for convenience in everyday cooking.
Here’s a detailed comparison to help you choose the right grill pan from All-Clad for your kitchen.
All-Clad NS1 Grill Pan
The All-Clad NS1 Grill Pan is crafted for home cooks who want professional-grade searing power and durability. Built with a solid tri-ply bonded construction, it excels at creating deep grill marks and a perfect crust on steaks, chops, and burgers. Its all-metal design makes it exceptionally sturdy and capable of handling a lifetime of high-heat cooking and vigorous use.
- What it is: A heavy-duty, tri-ply stainless steel grill pan designed for high-heat searing and creating authentic grill marks.
- Key features: Bonded stainless steel construction with an aluminum core for rapid, even heating. Oven and broiler safe up to 600°F. Dishwasher safe and induction-compatible.
- Price: Typically ranges from $150 to $180 for the 12-inch model.
- Materials/Construction: Features a durable tri-ply construction consisting of a magnetic stainless steel exterior, an aluminum core for heat conduction, and a stainless steel cooking surface.
- Style: Sleek, professional look with a polished stainless steel finish that suits any modern kitchen.
- Pros: Superior at high-heat searing, creating a distinct crust. Extremely durable construction can last a lifetime. Can handle metal utensils without damage. Dishwasher safe and compatible with all cooktops.
- Cons: Lacks a non-stick coating, so food may stick without proper technique and oiling. Heavier than the HA1. Requires more effort to clean after searing.
This grill pan is the ideal choice for anyone whose top priority is performance and longevity for cooking meats and hearty vegetables.
Shop this product: williams-sonoma.com/products/all-clad-ns1-nonstick-square-grill/
All-Clad HA1 Grill Pan
The All-Clad HA1 Grill Pan is designed for home cooks who value convenience and easy cleanup without sacrificing quality. Its hard-anodized aluminum construction paired with a high-performance, PFOA-free non-stick coating ensures food releases effortlessly. It is an excellent choice for everyday grilling of delicate items like fish and vegetables or for anyone who wants a more forgiving and user-friendly cooking experience.
- What it is: A non-stick grill pan with hard-anodized construction, perfect for everyday use and cooking delicate foods.
- Key features: Triple-layer PFOA-free non-stick coating for easy food release and cleaning. Anodized aluminum with a bonded stainless steel base for even heating and induction compatibility. Oven safe up to 500°F.
- Price: Slightly more affordable, usually priced from $130 to $160 for a 12-inch pan.
- Materials/Construction: Heavy-gauge, hard-anodized aluminum construction with a non-stick finish and a bonded steel induction base.
- Style: A practical and modern aesthetic with a matte black finish on the exterior and a dark, smooth non-stick interior.
- Pros: Excellent non-stick performance ensures easy food release. Very easy to clean. Lighter weight makes it easier to handle. Great for grilling delicate items that might stick to stainless steel. Lower price point.
- Cons: The non-stick coating has a finite lifespan and will eventually degrade. Cannot be used with metal utensils. Not ideal for extremely high-heat searing compared to the NS1. Lower oven-safe temperature (500°F vs 600°F).
The HA1 grill pan is perfect for those who prioritize convenience, quick cleanup, and a cookware piece that excels at everyday meals.
Shop this product: williams-sonoma.com/products/all-clad-ha1-nonstick-square-grill/
All-Clad NS1 vs. HA1 Grill Pan Comparison
Materials & Construction
The biggest difference lies here. The NS1 is made from a tri-ply bonded construction of stainless steel and aluminum. This build is designed for maximum heat retention and durability, making it feel substantial and built to last forever. Comparatively, the HA1 uses hard-anodized aluminum with a stainless steel base to make it induction-ready. While also very durable, its defining feature is the triple-layer non-stick coating on the interior, which makes it less suited for the ultra-high heat and metal utensils that the NS1 can handle.
Durability & Performance
When it comes to pure searing performance, the NS1 is the clear winner. Its stainless steel surface can be preheated to very high temperatures, creating a perfect, caramelized crust on steaks, burgers, and chicken. It’s a workhorse pan designed to withstand years of scrubbing and high heat. The HA1 performs exceptionally well for a non-stick pan, heating evenly and producing nice grill marks. However, its primary strength is convenience. Its non-stick coating, while durable, will wear down over time and must be protected from high heat and abrasive tools. The NS1's performance is tied to its material and technique, while the HA1's is tied to its coating.
Price & Value
The HA1 grill pan is generally more affordable, priced around $130 to $160, making it an excellent value for a high-quality non-stick pan. The NS1 comes in at a higher price point, typically $150 to $180. The value proposition for each is different. The HA1 offers immediate value through ease of use and convenience, but may need to be replaced in several years as the coating wears out. The NS1 represents a long-term investment, with proper care, it's a "buy it for life" piece of cookware.
Style & Ease of Use
Aesthetically, the NS1 brings a professional, polished stainless steel look to the kitchen. The HA1 has a more contemporary, sleek matte dark finish. In terms of use, the HA1 is far more user-friendly for beginners and those cooking delicate foods. Cleanup is often as simple as a quick wipe-down. The NS1 demands a bit more from the user - proper preheating and oiling techniques are necessary to prevent food from sticking, and it may require some soaking or scrubbing to clean thoroughly after use.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both All-Clad grill pans are excellent tools, but they serve different cooking philosophies and needs.
Choose the All-Clad NS1 if:
- You prioritize achieving a deep, professional-level sear on meats like steak and chops.
- You want a highly durable pan that can withstand high heat and metal utensils.
- You prefer to invest in cookware that can last a lifetime.
- You don't mind a more involved cleaning process in exchange for superior performance.
Choose the All-Clad HA1 if:
- You want the convenience of a high-quality non-stick surface for effortless food release.
- You often cook delicate items like fish, veggies, and boneless chicken breast.
- Easy and fast cleanup is a top priority for your everyday cooking routine.
- You are looking for a slightly more affordable but still high-performing option.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between the All-Clad NS1 and HA1?
The main difference is the cooking surface. The NS1 has a durable, tri-ply stainless steel surface designed for superior searing at high heat. The HA1 features a triple-layer, PFOA-free non-stick coating over hard-anodized aluminum for easy food release and cleanup.
Which pan is better for grilling steaks?
The All-Clad NS1 Grill Pan is better for steaks. Its stainless steel surface can get extremely hot and creates a better crust and sear marks compared to a non-stick surface, which isn't designed for sustained high-heat cooking.
Is the non-stick coating on the HA1 pan safe?
Yes, the HA1 grill pan uses a durable, PFOA-free non-stick coating that meets all modern safety standards. The key is to use it within its recommended temperature limits (up to 500°F) and avoid using metal utensils that can scratch the surface.
Can I use metal utensils on these pans?
You can use metal utensils with the NS1 stainless steel grill pan without issue. However, you should never use metal utensils on the HA1 grill pan, as it will scratch and ruin the non-stick coating. Stick to wood, silicone, or nylon tools.
Are both grill pans dishwasher safe?
Yes, both pans are officially listed as dishwasher safe by All-Clad. However, to prolong the life of the HA1's non-stick surface, it is highly recommended to hand wash it with a soft sponge, which is typically quite easy due to the coating.
Will these pans work on an induction stove?
Yes, both the NS1 and HA1 grill pans have a bonded stainless steel base that makes them fully compatible with all cooktops, including induction.
How long will the HA1's non-stick last?
With proper care - avoiding extreme heat, metal utensils, and abrasive scrubbing - the HA1's non-stick coating should last for several years of regular use. All non-stick coatings eventually degrade, but All-Clad's is known for its quality and durability.
Which pan is easier to clean?
The HA1 is significantly easier to clean. Its non-stick surface allows food debris to wipe away with minimal effort. The NS1 can develop a buildup of baked-on food particles, especially after high-heat searing, and may require soaking and scrubbing.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
